Welcome to Writers Talkback. If you are a new user, your account will have to be approved manually to prevent spam. Please bear with us in the meantime
THE LORD OF THE RINGS are incredible reads Jay! But, as hard as it is to say it on this occasion, each to their own.
A book I am struggling with at the moment would have to be Clare Morrals - The language of others. Her first novel was remarkable. Her second, awful and this one, well...it is so depressingly dull and...really rather badly written with cliched descriptions and cringeworthy dialogue.
It may have won some sort of award and they were even going to make a film about it.
Russell Crowe pulled out and that was the end of that.
The book, It was so boring
Years ago I began "Man and Boy" by Tony Parsons. Myself and a few colleagues used to go and buy a few books and discuss them whilst reading them. I couldn't bear the self-pitying tone of the main character and gave it up half-way through. It is one of the few books I found impossible to pick up. I usually can't put them down. Dreadful, dreadful stuff. I was reluctant to read anything my colleague chose, after that.
What about books you've read but should have given up reading. I persevered with Barbara Erskine's Daughters of Fire in the hope it would improve. I wished I'd saved myself the time and effort,
Susie, I felt the same about her book Midnight Echoes, or something. Dreadful, truly dreadful and historically inaccurate, too. I should know, as I talk to some of the people who she featured ... but apart from that, what she got wrong is in books, loads of them.
I am on the verge of giving up on Night train to Lisbon by Pascal Mercier.
Dire translation from the original German, full of textual errors and up to page 105 a very boring story so far.
I have jumped to another book meantime ( a bio) and will try and go back to Pascal Mercier's novel, but it really is hard going.
I never like to give up on a book once started but this is proving a struggle.
Yup, know what you mean about Barbara Erskine. The one that did my head in was the one about Matthew Hopkinson. But I finished it - I didn't finish The End of Mr Y by Scarlett Thomas - I loathed the main character, and someone, somewhere suggested I read some books whose titles included the word, 'Stonewylde'. The pretentious 'y' and 'e' in the spelling should have been the clue <SCREAMS LOUDLY, HANDS OVER EARS> I daren't say what I actually think for fear of causing offence...but I certainly didn't finish it...
Comments
A book I am struggling with at the moment would have to be Clare Morrals - The language of others. Her first novel was remarkable. Her second, awful and this one, well...it is so depressingly dull and...really rather badly written with cliched descriptions and cringeworthy dialogue.
It may have won some sort of award and they were even going to make a film about it.
Russell Crowe pulled out and that was the end of that.
The book, It was so boring
For Kaz.
Dire translation from the original German, full of textual errors and up to page 105 a very boring story so far.
I have jumped to another book meantime ( a bio) and will try and go back to Pascal Mercier's novel, but it really is hard going.
I never like to give up on a book once started but this is proving a struggle.